View source for Talk:Amaranth Eclipse (3.5e Martial Discipline)

== 404 ==

You know, I really like this discipline.  The flavor is cool, the powers are cool, there's just one small problem...

....none of the maneuvers have pre-reqs.    Did they forget them?  I'd love to use this but I can't use it without knowing the pre-reqs. -- [[User:Eiji-kun|Eiji-kun]] 13:00, 5 February 2011 (UTC)

:Why though? That maneuvers traditionally have prereqs doesn't make it a hard requirement that they should have them. I disagree with the winter cleaning tag and this message. [[User:Surgo|Surgo]] 19:09, 5 February 2011 (UTC)

::I would generally agree with this.  The author probably isn't going to see this, and it is otherwise good.  A warning that this discipline is without prerequisites would be useful, but deleting it completely would be a shame.  --[[User:Havvy|Havvy]] 20:41, 5 February 2011 (UTC)

:::I've placed a note on the user's talk page.  Thundergod Cid is active around here isn't he?  I think he'll see it, and it wasn't my intention of having it deleted, rather I was bringing note what I saw as a glaring flaw to an otherwise perfect work.  Now, I would argue that yes, maneuvers should have pre-reqs (the sole exception to the rule is so glaring I swear it was a typo, looking at you Tombstone Hammer....) but that's a debate for another day.

:::If you don't think he will notice this, I'll be happy to do the work.  Like I said, I like this discipline. -- [[User:Eiji-kun|Eiji-kun]] 00:17, 6 February 2011 (UTC)

::::Oh, I thought this was one of the transferred disciplines from before I got here.  Yeah, Cidolfas, if you want to add pre-reqs.  And the number of exceptions is actually quite higher in homebrew than in published material.  Also, many of my favorite maneuvers in Tome of Battle don't have pre-reqs despite being at a level they could have them. --[[User:Havvy|Havvy]] 00:32, 6 February 2011 (UTC)

== Rewriten summary ==
The summary looked a bit wordy for a summary, so I summarized it a bit more. Actual content of the page is unchanged, but feel free to undo if anyone's against the change.--[[User:Eromythic|Eromythic]] ([[User talk:Eromythic|talk]]) 05:06, 6 February 2022 (UTC)