View source for Talk:Creepy Kid (3.5e Feat)

== Ratings ==
{{Rating |rater=Undead Knave
|rating=neutral
|reason=This is a lot better than it was, although I'm not really fond of it.  It seems balanced enough that it isn't way off one way or another for VH, so I don't really have any reason to dislike it anymore, even if I don't actually like it.
}}
{{Rating |rater=Tarkisflux
|rating=neutral
|reason=The abilities are reasonable for the balance and hit die range, and are a serious step up from the old version. But the number manipulation is pretty meh and I'm not a fan of the inability to have creepy 'good' people or the requirement that you show evil to detect spells after a certain point. It seems unnecessary to the creepy fluff, and like it cuts off otherwise reasonable character options. Still, if you like archetype feats and are playing a VH game this is a pretty reasonable one to include.
}}
{{Rating |rater=ThunderGod Cid |block=NewVersion
|rating=oppose
|reason=Supporting what Surgo and DD said. The frightful presence was something I could kind of wrap my head around, since I think the 4d6 round duration, while excessive even then, is a straight port from SRD dragon entries. But the 15 HD ability is the real kicker, since it's ambiguous enough to make the character immune to everything that doesn't already not affect them.
}}
{{Rating |rater=DanielDraco |block=NewVersion
|rating=oppose
|reason=1 HD gives you nothing, and 3 HD gives you next to nothing; both are terrible even for L. 8 HD is suddenly VH, and laughably so -- 4d6 rounds is more time than anyone needs. Surgo is correct on the phrasing issues in 15 HD, and furthermore if it were corrected to do what you ''meant'' for it to do, it would be way too situational to be useful.
}}
{{Rating |rater=Surgo |block=NewVersion
|rating=oppose
|reason=This feat is off-the-chains crazy. Just reaching level 8 gives you a permanent aura of save-or-die. It does more than just that of course -- never make a Sense Motive check again (people will just start running around like chickens around you). The poorly-worded 15 HD ability gives you immunity to every spell in the game.
}}
Neutral	Undead Knave + and Tarkisflux +
UncountedRating	ThunderGod Cid +, DanielDraco + and Surgo +