Difference between revisions of "Talk:Freeze Blood (3.5e Spell)"
From Dungeons and Dragons Wiki
(→Response to Ratings: new section) |
|||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{rating |rater=The 42nd Gecko |rating=dislike |reason=This spell is Freeze Blood, a necromancy [cold] spell. But it seems in the efforts to make a balanced utilitarian save or die, it kinda tramped all over that. It isn't really freezing, or affecting blood, or a cold spell. The description and mechanics of the spell need to match up more.}} | {{rating |rater=The 42nd Gecko |rating=dislike |reason=This spell is Freeze Blood, a necromancy [cold] spell. But it seems in the efforts to make a balanced utilitarian save or die, it kinda tramped all over that. It isn't really freezing, or affecting blood, or a cold spell. The description and mechanics of the spell need to match up more.}} | ||
| − | {{Rating |rater=Eiji-kun |rating= | + | {{Rating |rater=Eiji-kun |rating=like |reason=<s>I am wary of death-immunity bypassing save or dies, but this has precedence (via Flesh to Stone). That said, though it looks like it does have a means of immunity though being a Cold spell, cold immunes are still effected, and I'm not sure why. Besides disagreeing with it bypassing, I don't know the mechanism in which they are being harmed if its not a cold effect. |
| − | I can't really being myself to disliking it, but consider this a negatively toned neither rating. I'll side with Gecko here.}} | + | I can't really being myself to disliking it, but consider this a negatively toned neither rating. I'll side with Gecko here.</s> |
| + | |||
| + | Oh, everything's ok now. Now it makes the sense.}} | ||
:In fairness, this seems an extraordinarily easy fix. Change the spell school to transmutation and you're good to go, in my opinion. Given that this isn't an actual death effect, just a save or die, doing so seems appropriate to me. - [[User:ThunderGod Cid|TG Cid]] 21:11, 2 July 2012 (UTC) | :In fairness, this seems an extraordinarily easy fix. Change the spell school to transmutation and you're good to go, in my opinion. Given that this isn't an actual death effect, just a save or die, doing so seems appropriate to me. - [[User:ThunderGod Cid|TG Cid]] 21:11, 2 July 2012 (UTC) | ||
Revision as of 01:17, 4 July 2012
|
The 42nd Gecko dislikes this article and rated it 1 of 4. |
|---|---|
| This spell is Freeze Blood, a necromancy [cold] spell. But it seems in the efforts to make a balanced utilitarian save or die, it kinda tramped all over that. It isn't really freezing, or affecting blood, or a cold spell. The description and mechanics of the spell need to match up more. |
|
Eiji-kun likes this article and rated it 3 of 4. |
|---|---|
| I can't really being myself to disliking it, but consider this a negatively toned neither rating. I'll side with Gecko here. Oh, everything's ok now. Now it makes the sense. |
- In fairness, this seems an extraordinarily easy fix. Change the spell school to transmutation and you're good to go, in my opinion. Given that this isn't an actual death effect, just a save or die, doing so seems appropriate to me. - TG Cid 21:11, 2 July 2012 (UTC)
Response to Ratings
I have responded to this criticism. Surgo 01:11, 4 July 2012 (UTC)
